Most people spend more time choosing a car than choosing their Medicare coverage. That is not a criticism. The Medicare system is genuinely complicated, and the decision you make at 65 is not always easy to undo. But the stakes are high enough that it deserves more than a quick comparison of monthly premiums.
The choice between Medicare Advantage and Medigap (also called Medicare Supplement) is one of the most consequential healthcare decisions you will make in retirement. It affects not just what you pay, but which doctors you can see, how much you might owe in a serious illness, and whether you will be able to change your mind later if your health or circumstances change.
Here is how to think through it clearly.
The Foundation: Original Medicare
Before comparing the two options, it helps to understand what they are built on. Original Medicare consists of Part A (hospital coverage) and Part B (outpatient and physician services). In 2026, the standard Part B premium is $202.90 per month, though higher-income enrollees pay more through IRMAA surcharges.[^1]
Original Medicare covers a substantial portion of healthcare costs, but it leaves meaningful gaps. There is no out-of-pocket maximum. Hospital stays beyond 60 days require daily coinsurance. Skilled nursing facility stays beyond 20 days carry a daily copay. And there is no coverage for most dental, vision, or hearing services.
Both Medicare Advantage and Medigap exist to fill these gaps, but they do so in fundamentally different ways.
Medicare Advantage: The All-in-One Option
Medicare Advantage (Part C) is offered by private insurance companies approved by Medicare. Instead of using Original Medicare directly, you receive all your Part A and Part B benefits through the private plan, which typically bundles in Part D drug coverage and often adds dental, vision, and hearing benefits.
The appeal is clear. Many Medicare Advantage plans carry $0 premiums beyond the standard Part B premium. In 2026, the maximum out-of-pocket limit for Medicare Advantage plans is $9,250 for in-network services.[^2] That cap provides protection against catastrophic costs that Original Medicare alone does not offer.
The tradeoff is network restrictions. Most Medicare Advantage plans are HMOs or PPOs, which means you need to use in-network providers or pay significantly more. Referrals are often required to see specialists. Prior authorization requirements can delay or complicate access to certain treatments.
For someone who is generally healthy, lives in an area with strong plan networks, and values the simplicity of a single card and a low premium, Medicare Advantage can work well.
Medigap: The Predictability Option
Medigap plans work alongside Original Medicare. You keep Original Medicare as your primary coverage, and the Medigap policy pays most or all of the cost-sharing that Medicare does not cover: deductibles, copays, and coinsurance.
Plan G is one Medigap option to compare. Its coverage, exclusions, premiums, availability, and the annual Part B deductible should be verified against current Medicare and insurer materials before a coverage decision.[^3]
The result is highly predictable healthcare spending. You pay your Part B premium, your Medigap premium (typically $150 to $300 per month depending on age and location), and your Part B deductible once per year. After that, you can see any doctor in the country who accepts Medicare, with no network restrictions, no referrals, and no prior authorization for Medicare-covered services.
For someone who travels frequently, has established relationships with specialists, or has a chronic condition requiring ongoing specialist care, the freedom of Medigap is often worth the higher premium.
The Comparison That Actually Matters
Most comparisons focus on monthly premiums. That is the wrong place to start.
| Factor | Medicare Advantage | Medigap (Plan G) |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly premium (beyond Part B) | Often $0 | $150 to $300/month |
| Out-of-pocket maximum | $9,250/year (in-network) | Effectively $257/year (Part B deductible only) |
| Network restrictions | Yes (HMO or PPO) | None (any Medicare provider) |
| Referrals required | Often yes | No |
| Prior authorization | Common | Rare |
| Drug coverage | Usually included | Requires separate Part D plan |
| Dental/vision/hearing | Often included | Not included |
| Ability to switch later | Limited | Restricted after initial enrollment |
The last row in that table is the one that surprises people most.
The Switching Problem
When you first enroll in Medicare at 65, you have a six-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period during which insurers must accept you regardless of health status and cannot charge you more based on pre-existing conditions.[^4] After that window closes, switching to Medigap in most states requires medical underwriting. If you have developed health conditions since you enrolled in Medicare Advantage, you may be denied coverage or charged significantly higher premiums.
This asymmetry matters enormously. Someone who enrolls in Medicare Advantage at 65 because the $0 premium is attractive, and then develops a serious illness at 70 that requires frequent specialist visits or out-of-network care, may find themselves unable to switch to Medigap when they most need its predictability.
The reverse is not true. Someone who starts with Medigap can generally switch to Medicare Advantage at any annual enrollment period without medical underwriting, because Medicare Advantage plans are required to accept all Medicare-eligible enrollees.
How to Think About This Decision
The right choice depends on your health, your finances, and your priorities. Here is the framework I use with clients.
If you are in good health at 65 and your primary concern is keeping monthly costs low, Medicare Advantage may serve you well for years. The key question is whether you are comfortable with the possibility that switching later may be difficult or impossible if your health changes.
If you have a chronic condition, established specialist relationships, or a strong preference for predictable costs regardless of what happens medically, Medigap is likely the better long-term choice, even though the upfront premium is higher.
If you are uncertain, the more conservative choice is to start with Medigap during your Open Enrollment Period, when you have guaranteed access regardless of health status. You can always move to Medicare Advantage later. The reverse is not guaranteed.
One more consideration: if you are still working at 65 and covered by an employer plan, you may have the option to delay Medicare enrollment without penalty. That decision has its own set of rules and tradeoffs worth understanding before you act.
The Bottom Line
Medicare Advantage and Medigap are not equally flexible options. One of them is much harder to leave than the other, and that asymmetry should weigh heavily in your decision at 65.
The lower premium of Medicare Advantage is real. So is the network restriction, the prior authorization burden, and the underwriting risk if you want to switch later. Medigap costs more upfront but delivers something that is genuinely hard to put a price on: the ability to see any doctor who accepts Medicare, anywhere in the country, with predictable out-of-pocket costs for the rest of your life.
This is not a decision to make based on a comparison chart alone. It is a decision that belongs in the context of your overall retirement income plan, your health history, and your priorities for the years ahead.
References
[^1]: Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. "Medicare Part B Premium and Deductible for 2026." CMS.gov. Standard Part B premium: $202.90/month. https://www.cms.gov/newsroom/fact-sheets/2026-medicare-parts-b-premiums-and-deductibles
[^2]: National Council on Aging. "What Is the Difference Between Medicare Advantage and Medigap?" NCOA.org. 2026 Medicare Advantage out-of-pocket maximum: $9,250 in-network. https://www.ncoa.org/article/what-is-the-difference-between-medicare-advantage-and-medigap/
[^3]: Medicare.gov. "Compare Medigap Plan Benefits." Medicare.gov. Plan G covers all cost-sharing except the Part B deductible. https://www.medicare.gov/health-drug-plans/medigap/basics/compare-plan-benefits
[^4]: Medicare.gov. "Medigap Open Enrollment Period." Medicare.gov. Six-month guaranteed issue period begins when you enroll in Part B at age 65 or older. https://www.medicare.gov/health-drug-plans/medigap/basics/when-can-i-buy-medigap
Jason Rindskopf is the founder of Two Waters Wealth Management and creator of the SMART Retirement Blueprint®. He works with high-achieving professionals and couples in the Charlotte, NC area who are within 10 years of retirement or recently retired. If you'd like to talk through your Medicare coverage decisions and healthcare planning in retirement, book a complimentary consultation here.